If you're thinking about selling your home yourself, let me start with something most real estate agents won't say: that instinct deserves respect, not a sales pitch.
The commission on a home sale is real money — potentially thousands of dollars — and questioning whether you need to pay it is exactly the kind of thinking a smart homeowner does. So instead of scare tactics, here's the honest math: the newest national data (including the parts that favor going alone), and what it all means here in the Georgia CSRA.
The Headline Numbers
Every year, the National Association of REALTORS® publishes its Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers — the most comprehensive dataset on how Americans actually buy and sell homes. The newest edition, published November 2025, covers transactions from July 2024 through June 2025. Here's what it found:
- Homes sold by owner went for a median of $360,000. Homes sold with an agent went for a median of $425,000 — a $65,000 gap at the median.
- Only 5% of sellers went FSBO last year — an all-time low for the survey, which has run since 1981.
- A record 91% of sellers used an agent, up from 90% the year before.
On the raw numbers, sellers with agents came out far ahead. But I promised you honesty, so before you take that $65,000 gap at face value, you need to know what it actually measures.
Why I Won't Just Quote That Gap and Stop
That comparison is a raw median — it compares all FSBO sales against all agent-assisted sales, without controlling for what kind of house was sold. And the two groups aren't selling the same kind of houses:
- FSBO homes skew smaller and more affordable. In the 2025 profile they were most common among mobile or manufactured homes (16% of such sales) and in rural areas (10% of sales), versus just 3% in suburban areas and subdivisions.
- Most expensive, move-in-ready homes sell with agents.
- And the biggest distortion of all: in the 2025 profile, 60% of FSBO sales involved a buyer the seller already knew — a relative, a friend, a neighbor. Selling to someone they already knew was actually the single most common reason sellers gave for going FSBO (30%), and those sales never had to survive the open market at all.
So the honest version is this: the gap is real, but it's overstated for a like-for-like house. Which raises the fairer question — when you compare similar homes, does selling alone actually come out ahead after you pocket the saved commission?
The Fairer Comparison
The 2025 profile itself offers a cleaner cut: among FSBO sellers who did not know their buyer — the closest thing in the data to a genuinely marketed FSBO — the median sale price was $372,200. That is the like-for-like comparison: $372,200 sold by owner versus $425,000 with an agent, still a gap of roughly $53,000 before any commission savings are counted against it.
Outside the NAR data, a widely cited 2017 Collateral Analytics study compared FSBO and agent-assisted sales while controlling for home characteristics. The finding: FSBO sellers netted the same or slightly less than agent-assisted sellers — even accounting for the commission they saved.
The reason is a line every buyer's agent knows by heart: the seller and the buyer can't both save the same commission. When buyers see a home listed by its owner, they know no commission is being paid on the listing side — and they price that "savings" into their offer. The money you're trying to keep is exactly what they're trying to negotiate away. In practice, the saved commission gets split at the negotiating table rather than pocketed.
Does FSBO Take Longer to Sell?
Here is where I have to be more honest than most agents will be. In the 2025 profile, completed FSBO sales actually moved fast: a median of one week on market, versus three weeks for agent-assisted sales. On its face, that sounds like a win for going alone. But three asterisks matter more than the headline:
- Most of those "fast" sales were pre-arranged. FSBO sellers who already knew their buyer reported a median of zero weeks on market. When a relative buys your house, there was never a search.
- The survey only counts winners. NAR surveys sellers who completed a sale. Sellers who tried FSBO, could not get it done, and then hired an agent appear as their own group — and they spent the longest on market of anyone in the data (four weeks median), with 58% cutting their asking price three or more times along the way.
- FSBO homes skew cheaper, and cheaper homes sell faster. A comparison of weeks is not comparing the same kinds of houses.
For the FSBO seller genuinely marketing to strangers, the structural limits are real: 88% of buyers purchased through an agent last year, and agents overwhelmingly search the MLS, the shared database of listed homes. A home that is not on the MLS is invisible to nearly the entire professional buyer pool. Meanwhile, 40% of FSBO sellers in the profile did not actively market their home at all, and the top methods for those who did were a yard sign and word of mouth (24% and 22%).
When NAR asked FSBO sellers what their hardest tasks were, the top answers: getting the price right (17%), preparing the home for sale (12%), selling within their planned timeframe (10%), and handling the paperwork (7%). That first number matters most. Pricing is where FSBO sales are won or lost. Price too high and the home sits while the market moves on; price too low and you have handed the buyer the money you were trying to save.
When FSBO Genuinely Makes Sense
Here's the part where going alone can win:
- You already have your buyer. A neighbor mentioned they'd love your house, a coworker asked if you'd ever sell — if the buyer came to you, the exposure argument disappears, and a direct sale can make real sense.
- You value the process as much as the outcome. Some sellers genuinely enjoy handling showings, negotiation, and paperwork, and are willing to trade weeks of their time for the commission.
NAR's own data agrees with both bullets. Among sellers who already knew their buyer, 38% sold the home themselves. Among sellers who did not know their buyer, 96% used an agent and only 2% went alone. When there is no buyer waiting in the wings, the market almost always ends up hiring a professional anyway.
If that's your situation, a direct sale is worth running the numbers. But notice both scenarios require something specific: you already have the buyer the open market was supposed to find.
What the CSRA Numbers Say Right Now
Local context matters, because FSBO math changes with the market. In a hot market where every home gets multiple offers, going alone is easier. In a balanced market, exposure does the heavy lifting.
Here's the Georgia CSRA as of September 2026 (Realtor.com data):
- Columbia County: 1,385 active listings, up 13% year over year, with a median of 69 days on market.
- Richmond County: 1,333 active listings, up 17% year over year, with a median of 68 days on market.
One honest caveat about applying any of this locally: no published dataset compares FSBO and agent-assisted sale prices for the Augusta area, or for Georgia at all. Homes sold without an agent often never enter the MLS, so local FSBO sales are largely invisible to the market statistics anyone can look up. The national data above, paired with verified local market figures, is the strongest evidence available. If anyone quotes you precise "local FSBO" numbers, ask where they came from before you trust them.
Rising inventory means buyers have choices — and a buyer with choices needs to see your home, in professional photos, priced on real comparable data, to choose it. The same dynamics play out across the river in Aiken County, South Carolina; the CSRA is one regional economy with one housing market rhythm. (I'm licensed in Georgia, so I'll stay in my lane and speak to the Georgia side of the line.)
The Bottom Line
FSBO works when you already have your buyer. When you don't, the data says the commission you're trying to save gets shared with the buyer in negotiation — and the sale usually takes longer.
If you're weighing FSBO versus an agent, don't decide based on a blog post — including this one. Do the math with real numbers for your house: what homes near you actually sold for in the last 12 months, what your timeline is really worth, and what professional marketing would add.
You can start free at nickjefftherealtor.com — create an account and browse the Neighborhood Profiles to see actual sold data for over 500 CSRA neighborhoods, including the ones near you.
Or call me at (706) 945-1267 for a free, no-pressure consultation. I'll walk the honest math with you — and if selling it yourself is genuinely your best move, I'll tell you that.
Sources
- National Association of REALTORS®, 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (published Nov. 4, 2025; transactions July 2024–June 2025; FSBO figures from Chapter 8 of the full report). The 2026 edition arrives in November.
- Collateral Analytics (2017), study of FSBO versus agent-assisted home sales, controlling for home characteristics.
- Realtor.com, Columbia and Richmond County market data (September 2026).
Nicholas Jefferson, Licensed Georgia Real Estate Agent | Realty ONE Group Visionaries | (706) 945-1267
📍 Serving Augusta, Evans, Grovetown, Martinez, Harlem, GA & surrounding areas
October 06, 2026 at 05:24 AM by Nick Jeff the Realtor's Blog AI Agent
(Updated October 07, 2026 at 05:51 PM)

Comments
Comments are reviewed before they appear publicly.
No approved comments yet.
Log in to leave a comment.